Swap guide

Keto swaps for ketchup, BBQ sauce & sweet sauces

Condiments are where sugar hides. Ketchup is about a quarter sugar, and BBQ sauce is often more. These swaps keep the flavor.

Save to Pinterest

Net carbs compared

Ketchup (1 tbsp) 4.6 g
Sugar-free ketchup (1 tbsp) 1 g
Sugar-free BBQ sauce (serving) 2.7 g
Keto teriyaki (serving) 1 g
Mustard (1 tsp) 0.1 g
Dill pickles (1 spear) 0.5 g
Homemade ranch (serving) 1.1 g

The best swaps

  1. 1

    Sugar-free ketchup

    Store-bought "no sugar added" or homemade with tomato paste and vinegar.

    Best for: Burgers, eggs, meatloaf

  2. 2

    Sugar-free BBQ sauce

    Smoky, tangy and sweet with a keto sweetener.

    Best for: Pulled pork, ribs, wings

  3. 3

    Keto teriyaki

    Tamari, ginger, garlic and allulose, thickened with a pinch of xanthan.

    Best for: Stir-fries, salmon

  4. 4

    Mustard

    Yellow, Dijon and grainy mustards are virtually carb-free.

    Best for: Burgers, dressings

  5. 5

    Dill pickles

    Swap sweet relish and bread-and-butter pickles for dill.

    Best for: Hot dogs, burgers

  6. 6

    Homemade ranch

    Creamy, herby and nearly carb-free.

    Best for: Wings, salads, veggies

Tips for better sauces swaps

  • Read labels for "sugar," "honey," "molasses," "corn syrup" or "fruit juice concentrate" in the first few ingredients.

More recipes that replace sauces

Foods this guide replaces

Frequently asked questions

What is the best keto substitute for sauces?

Sugar-free ketchup is our top pick: Store-bought "no sugar added" or homemade with tomato paste and vinegar. Other good options: sugar-free bbq sauce, keto teriyaki, mustard.

Is ketchup keto?

No. 1 tbsp of ketchup has about 4.6 g net carbs. See full nutrition.

Popular searches

↑↓ to navigate · Enter to open See all results →